"Deserve"? No. People don't deserve second chances. We, and that is
we folks, not
"they", unless you aren't classified under the heading "people." We don't deserve second chances, but it's still good and noble to give them. Why? "Do unto others as you'd have done unto you." Do I screw up? Yes. Do I desire grace and forgiveness when I do? Absolutely.
However, a second chance, to my mind, means giving someone the opportunity to regain trust this is broken,
when they truly get a clue and realize they've done wrong. Giving second chances to one who is not sorry is assuming the position of doormat, a great place to wipe dirty feet.
With regard to my reaction to the word deserve:
–verb (used with object)
1. to merit, be qualified for, or have a claim to (reward, assistance, punishment, etc.) because of actions, qualities, or situation: to deserve exile; to deserve charity; a theory that deserves consideration.
How can we claim one
deserves the opposite of what their behavior demonstrates? For someone to screw up and then we say they deserve a second chance is just not logical. They screw up, but out of a heart of compassion and hope for a better outcome, one can choose to show them that they are highly valued by giving them a second chance. The whole point of a second chance is in that it's not based on their merit or what they deserve but on the individual's choice to demonstrate love and mercy. As soon as you enter into the realm of "but I deserve a second chance" as some inalienable right, then we're on dangerous and potentially arrogant ground.
Yeah, he/she/we did ________ but, he/she/we deserve a second chance? Not likely. Even so, I will humbly hope for one.
(F-list excuse the rant. The answers to this question got under my skin.)